I find it very meaningful to provide aid to friends when they need it. I find it fun and sweet to do something nice for my friends, even if they’re not at all well described as needing it.

I’ve realized that I should really be including Scott’s disclaimer at the top of all of my posts so here: disclaimer. Ok actually I won’t do that, but do go read the post, it’s excellent.

Often times, people don’t voice ways that they’d appreciate or “need” help, because they’re worried about inconveniencing the other person or pressuring the other person into helping when the other person doesn’t really want to in a way that they anticipate would lead to their friend feeling annoyed with them. Maybe people are worried about a friend declining to help them, and that being painful. Sometimes people see being self sufficient as a favor they can do for their friends.

I realized this is confusing because of a backpack. My friend said “I’d like to carry this backpack”. And I said “no, I’d like to carry this backpack”. And we were at an impasse of infinite regress: to carry a backpack for a friend would certainly be a nice favor, unless the real thing that they wanted was the pleasure of carrying your backpack to do something nice for you, unless the real thing they wanted was the pleasure of giving you the pleasure of you carrying their backpack, and so on. Fortunately this type of situation isn’t really a big deal. Either there will be an asymmetry in how much pain it causes ppl to carry the backpack and how much pleasure they derive from it, or this asymmetry isn’t clear and you should flip a coin and not think about it too hard or make a big deal of it. (ofc there are some brutal “mechanism design for fship”-style qs here; but that’s a project for a later day).

I don’t want to take much of a stance here on how if at all one should modify their self-conception of what their needs are. I’m going to instead for simplicity assume needs are fairly static, and that what isn’t static is bars for accepting and asking for help.

Here are some things I advocate for:

Have a lower bar for accepting help. If you don’t really need your friends water on a hike, but you’re kind of thirsty and they offered it to you, accept!

One type of time when people could use some help is when they’re feeling sad. But for some ppl feeling sad is associated with feelings of low self esteem, or doubting that other ppl care about them. Sad ppl are also relatively likely to feel like they’re imposing on ppl when asking for help. If you system-1-know about this bias, you can correct for it in times when you system-2-don’t believe it.

If there’s sth that’d be valuable to you, don’t wait for other ppl to mind read you and guess it — they probably won’t — consider telling them. This includes giving critical feedback (eg when you said this it made me sad, can you not say that later, also can you help me understand why you said it?).

tag:none