Kahneman claims that the remembered valence of a memory depends largely on the peak valence and the final valence. For instance, people remember a surgery more fondly if you add a period of mild discomfort at the end of it! IIUC Kahneman came to this hypothesis via mildly torturing people in different ways and seeing which ones they preferred (and testing some causal interventions).1
Ultimately, I care about the aggregate quality of observer moments in the universe, not the quality of my memories. However, memories are a hugely important part of my experience! Memory is the reason why N can say ācocoa powder beansā and Iāll burst out laughing. Itās why I smile when I see an orange (oranges have existed in dozens of happy contexts with P).
Therefore, to maximize the quality of my subjective experience it is expedient to understand how to have good memories. This post, loosely inspired by Kahnemanās analysis, will think about how to do this.
Thanks to TL, AP, NS, and MK for some stimulating discussions about memory :)
Note: Iām not super confident Iāve gotten everything right here. Excited to discuss with people, open to pushback.
Keeping activities lean can make memories better
Note: Iām not super confidence that lean-ness is a real or useful concept. tbd.
A naive read of Kahnemanās peak-end rule is that we should try to end experiences on really good notes to maximize the quality of a memory. In particular, if we feel like weāve probably hit the peak of an interaction, we should end the interaction immediately to maximize the memoryās valence. Now, this might sound silly, or horrible. Ultimately, itās not the right way to live. But directionally updating towards having more āleanā activities has some merits.
Keeping an activity lean means not diluting the experience with extraneous parts or things which are less good than the central part of the activity. It means being pretty picky about tacking extra things onto an activity. Lean activities might feel like when you have a 10 minute phone call with a friend, because of some time constraints, so you just say everything important as fast as you can. Lean activities are like having a really short and efficient meeting at work or a talk that is very to the point.
Leanness encourages keeping activities crisp and making the important parts easier to remember. Having time pressure / a deadline on an activity can cause people to make the most of an activity, to treat every moment of the activity as more precious than they o/w would. Leanness is good b/c it it thoughtful of the opp cost of activities.
Having the ability to have lean experiences can open up the possibility of having more experiences. Possibly its the case that Iād feel kind of uncomfortable / vaguely bad about calling my friend for an hour today (bc Iām busy), but Iād love talking for 10 mins. Then itās good to be able to call for 10 mins. If you intentionally make an activity lean like this, that can be extra fun, bc you can feel disciplined when you successfully cap the activity at being short.
Another nice thing about keeping activities lean is that itās a way of being direct and honest with friends. And it feels nice if your friendship is close enough that you feel comfortable and secure doing this. and you arenāt worried about them thinking that you donāt like spending time w/ them.
Maybe a lean activity is you end the activity on a good silly joke.
OK, no. Hereās really what a lean activity is: The feeling of a lean activity is Youāve just had an amazing, intense, sincere conversation with your friend. Youāre smiling. You donāt feel a desperate need to hold onto the sands of the positive experience, the sand would just slip through your fingers. Instead you feel that it was enough, and that it was right. You feel confident and hopeful. You part ways b/c you have some understanding that poetically this moment was the right note to end the interaction on.
My overall recommendations here are:
- Maybe sometimes create lean activities on purpose in advance.
- Maybe sometimes keep activities lean rather than bloating them as you go.
Reasons not to keep activities āshortā
To balance it out, here are a few counter-considerations against keeping activities short. Note that short and lean are pretty different, but somewhat related.
Trying to leave āat the peakā of an experience can be bad for several reasons. One reason is that you canāt know when youāve hit the peak (altho secretary problem odds arenāt so bad). Another reason is that the experiences themselves were valuable, not just the memory. Itād be terrible advice to leave a relationship at the peak time of the relationship.
Some forms of trying to optimize away bad parts of experiences can be ways of not acknowledging bad world states, or can feel like youāre only contingently there for your friend.
Having lots of short interactions can be bad bc of context switching, a point in favor of having more extended activities.
Finally, I think āhanging out all day, not necc a plan, just with sureness that we enjoy spending time tgt and will think of some enjoyable way to spend the timeā is a pretty nice type of experience.
Memory is made by telling stories about the past
Kahnemanās peak-end rule is only really true on a short time scale for memories. In the longer term, the quality of our memories is purely determined by the stories we tell about the past. We can choose to emphasize or focus on whatever part we want. There isnāt one objectively right way to compress a memory ā all are lossy in different ways.
My most important piece of advice here is to actually intentionally make memories. When you have an amazing experience, write it down in detail (and maybe share it with the counterparty!).
When youāre having a great memory, make a mnemonic for it. Maybe you associate this shirt youāre wearing with the memory. A short catchy phrase is also a pretty good way to make it more likely you remember something.
Rehearse these memory cues. Especially via obscure references that are impossible to understand if your friend doesnāt remember the relevant thing.
Remember that the above advice is supposed to be a directional update, and its possible to go too far. Itās not good to live in the past too much. Itās not good to hold too tightly to memories: if itās hard to hold to a memory, thatās some evidence that itās not worth holding to that memory.
In closing, Iād like to say: Walrus, ginger, cat, white shirt, vitamin c, garlic, beach, blackboard, river, star market, kgzw, vanilla twilight, hypercube, bus, cooperate bot, steppenlobster. i miss you guys. but i have some window into these other parts of our 4D picture ā I can see us, and threads of us memory connecting us. the picture is good. i am happy to remember.
Footnotes
-
This story only holds for unipolar experiences: experiences whose valence is either largely positive or largely negative. Things are a bit more complicated for multipolar experiences. For multipolar experiences, some notes are: (1) we remember negative valence experiences more. (2) order and trend matter. - mixed sequence ā final part matters most. - improving sequence is better, even if total is fixed. Relief from pain or fear is a peak, so adding a scary part to a movie can make it better. ā©